A recent Chronicle of Higher Education article about Utah’s post-tenure-review audit raises questions that extend well beyond tenure: What preparation should universities require of the people they hire to teach? How should they reward effective teaching? And who is equipped to evaluate it?
Students deserve effective instruction, and universities have an obligation to address persistent underperformance. That responsibility begins with ensuring that faculty members are prepared for the teaching their jobs require.
Subject expertise and teaching expertise are distinct. Knowing a field deeply does not necessarily prepare someone to design a course, assess learning, explain difficult concepts, or provide feedback that helps students improve. These are professional skills that require development.
Yet faculty members can enter academic careers with extensive preparation as researchers and limited formal preparation as teachers. In hiring practices I have observed at R1 institutions, candidates have delivered research presentations without being required to give teaching demonstrations. In my experience, teaching demonstrations have been more common at smaller institutions with a stronger teaching emphasis.
These practices communicate priorities. When an institution hires primarily for research accomplishments and makes research the strongest currency for advancement, faculty members receive a clear message about where to invest their effort.
If teaching is part of the job, preparation to teach should be a requirement of the job.
Universities should establish a foundational teaching requirement for faculty members with instructional responsibilities. Faculty who have already completed meaningful preparation should be able to demonstrate it. Those who have not should receive structured preparation through their institution, with time and support to complete it as an expectation of employment.
That preparation should address how students learn, course design, assessment, feedback, accessibility, and effective instructional strategies. It should include opportunities to practice, receive informed feedback, and demonstrate the ability to apply what they have learned. Attendance at an orientation or a single workshop is insufficient preparation for an ongoing professional responsibility.
The requirement should also recognize that teaching develops over time. Foundational preparation should lead into continuing professional learning, mentoring, and periodic review. As faculty members encounter different students, teaching environments, and technologies, they should be expected and supported to adapt their practice.
This obligation belongs to both the individual and the institution. Faculty members are responsible for developing their teaching skills and responding to credible feedback. Universities are responsible for providing the preparation, time, resources, and expectations that make that development possible.
Preparation alone, however, will accomplish too little if institutional rewards continue to point elsewhere.
Universities need to reward effective teaching in consequential ways through compensation, promotion, tenure, and post-tenure review. At R1 institutions, teaching excellence should carry meaningful professional weight, just as research excellence does. Faculty members should see a clear connection between the quality of their teaching and their opportunities for advancement.
The same attention to preparation should extend to those who evaluate instruction. Department chairs frequently emerge from the same faculty preparation and reward systems as the colleagues they supervise. Their appointment does not, by itself, establish expertise in teaching, evaluating instruction, or mentoring someone who is struggling.
Giving chairs greater authority cannot substitute for preparing them to exercise it. Likewise, placing evaluation primarily in the hands of faculty peers does not automatically ensure that reviewers share a well-developed understanding of effective teaching.
Whether chairs answer primarily to faculty members or institutional leaders, they need preparation and access to instructional expertise. Disciplinary knowledge remains essential, and it should be complemented by knowledge of teaching and learning. Partnerships with teaching centers, instructional designers, and experienced faculty mentors can strengthen this work while preserving faculty participation in academic decisions.
Meaningful accountability also requires credible evaluation. Student feedback can identify problems that deserve attention, but satisfaction surveys alone cannot establish instructional effectiveness. Evaluation should draw on multiple sources, including informed peer review, course design, assessments, student work, and evidence of how instructors respond to feedback. Expectations should be clear enough for faculty members to work toward and for reviewers to assess fairly.
Tenure and academic freedom remain essential protections. They preserve the ability to challenge assumptions, teach difficult material, and exercise scholarly judgment. Those protections are compatible with requiring teaching preparation and expecting faculty members to develop and employ effective instructional practices.
Lack of preparation cannot excuse persistent neglect or a refusal to improve. Students should not bear the consequences indefinitely. Universities should provide clear expectations, appropriate support, and a reasonable opportunity to improve, then act when persistent underperformance continues.
The questions raised by teaching accountability reach across the entire faculty career, from graduate preparation and hiring through promotion and post-tenure review. Addressing problems only after years of ineffective instruction means intervening far too late.
Universities should require preparation for teaching, support its continued development, and reward its effective practice. If we expect faculty members to succeed as educators, those expectations must be built into the job from the beginning.


